1. Introduction
Nigeria's overdependence on mono-economy created a drawback to economic growth and development. Fluctuation in the global oil, national wide insurgencies, banditry, militancy and kidnapping are various delirious activities rocking the political atmosphere in Nigeria constituted to low revenue generation through oil proceeds
[10] | Ogungbade, O. I., Enitan, A. & Adekoya, C. (2021). Tax Awareness, Tax payer’s Perceptions and Attitudes and Tax Evasion in Informal Sector of Ekiti State, Nigeria. International Journal of Financial Research, 12(5), 24-40. |
[10]
The drop in oil revenue generation serve as eye-opener to diversify the economy to alternative sources of revenue which includes tax revenue. Tax is a fiscal policy instrument used by government to stimulate economic growth
[10] | Ogungbade, O. I., Enitan, A. & Adekoya, C. (2021). Tax Awareness, Tax payer’s Perceptions and Attitudes and Tax Evasion in Informal Sector of Ekiti State, Nigeria. International Journal of Financial Research, 12(5), 24-40. |
[10]
. Economic growth and development is contingent on the revenue generation and its availability is necessary to meet both government capital and recurrent expenditures of government
[1] | Abdu, A. M. and Wondimu, S. (2019). Analysis of Tax Compliance and its Determinants: Evidence from Kaffa, Bendi, Maji and Sheka Zones Category B Taxpayers, SNNPR, Ethiopia. Journal of Accounting, Finance and Auditing Studies, 5(1), 32-58. |
[2] | Ahmed, B. M, Abubakar, A, Abdulkarim, G, Badamosi, H &Abdulaziz, A. (2023). Tax Revenue Effect on Government Revenue Generation in Nigeria. Gusau Journal of Economics and Development Studies, 3(1), 1-5. |
[1, 2]
. Taxes are mandatory charges on taxable income of individuals, sole proprietorships, partnership and corporate entities
[14] | Salawu, M. K., Okesina, S. O &Olabode, B. M. (2023). Determinants of Tax Non-Compliance Behaviour among Small and Medium Enterprises in Oyo State, Nigeria. Twist, 18(4), 344-353. |
[14]
. Formal sector have witnessed strictly tax law enforcement, awareness and investigation which constitute high level of tax compliance within the sectors. Income taxes such as Pay As You Earn and Corporate taxes contribute to more than 60% of the tax revenue in Nigeria. Akinyiga however views that tax revenue to gross domestic product is about 6% in 2020 which considerably very low compare to 26% in South Africa
[4] | Akinyiga, A. A. (2021). Tax Revenue to Gross Domestic Product Ratio. FIRS Quarterly Report. |
[4]
. Informal Sector is not easily defined. There is no consensus among the existing literatures as regard definitions and scope of informal economy
[11] | Ogunsola, I B &Karztelnik, K. (2022). Observation Study of Tax Compliance and Tax Evasion in Nigeria. 6(5), 1-13. |
[11]
. Small and Medium Enterprises dominate informal Sector of the economy, despite there is low tax compliance within the sectors. Salawu et al opine that about 6,131 SMEs were registered in Oyo State, despite there is low tax revenue generation
[14] | Salawu, M. K., Okesina, S. O &Olabode, B. M. (2023). Determinants of Tax Non-Compliance Behaviour among Small and Medium Enterprises in Oyo State, Nigeria. Twist, 18(4), 344-353. |
[14]
. Oyegun and Efangwu opine that geometric progression in Nigerian population does not match the tax revenue generation since majority of the population falls within the informal Sector of the economy
[13] | Oyegun, G & Efangwu, U N. (2023). Taxation and Economic Growth in Nigeria. Journal of Economics, Finance andInnovation, 2(10), 17-32. |
[13]
. One of the challenges of the tax administration in the sector, is how to draw potential tax payers to the tax net
[13] | Oyegun, G & Efangwu, U N. (2023). Taxation and Economic Growth in Nigeria. Journal of Economics, Finance andInnovation, 2(10), 17-32. |
[11] | Ogunsola, I B &Karztelnik, K. (2022). Observation Study of Tax Compliance and Tax Evasion in Nigeria. 6(5), 1-13. |
[13, 11]
. Tax compliance is the payment of appropriate income taxes within the provisions of tax laws. Non tax compliance within the informal sector is characterized with poor tax awareness and education, wrong perceptions of tax payers to tax payment and negative attitudes toward tax payment. Okeke et al view the sector as unobserved and unprotected sectors due to the peculiarities. Many have poor education about taxes while some have wrong attitude toward tax payment
[12] | Okeke, C. A, Nwogwugwu, U C, Ezenekwe, R. U, Uzonwanne, M. C &Ekwoh, G. A. (2023). Inclusive Growth and Informal Sector Growth in Enugu State, Nigeria. Journal of Economics Studies, 20(1), 394-413. |
[12]
. Moore opines that tax administrations waste a lot of resources within informal sector in sub Saharan Africa as the sector is under taxed
[7] | Moore, M. (2022). Tax Obsessions: Tax Registration and the Informal Sector in Sub-Saharan Africa. www.wileyonlinelibrary.org retrieved on 3rd March, 2024. |
[7]
.
1.1. Objective of the Study
The study investigates the impact of taxpayers' awareness and tax payers' perceptions on tax compliance of Informal sector within Oyo North Senatorial District, Nigeria. The following specific objectives are investigated:
i) The impact of taxpayers' awareness and education on tax compliance of Informal sector in Oyo North Senatorial District.
ii) The impact of taxpayers' perceptions on tax compliance of Informal sector in Oyo North Senatorial District.
1.2. Hypotheses
Ho1: Taxpayers’ awareness and education have no significant impact on tax compliance of informal sector in Oyo North Senatorial District.
Ho2: Taxpayers’ perceptions have no significant impact on tax compliance of informal sector in Oyo North Senatorial District.
2. Literature Review
2.1. Concept of Informal Sector
Informal sector is the proportion of an economy which is not adequately regulated by a specific law in the nation. This aspect of the economy is strictly moderated by various trade associations which may or may not be registered with appropriate authority. Moore views informal sectors as unproductive taxpayers' sector
[7] | Moore, M. (2022). Tax Obsessions: Tax Registration and the Informal Sector in Sub-Saharan Africa. www.wileyonlinelibrary.org retrieved on 3rd March, 2024. |
[7]
. The view is supported by the study that majority of the operators in the sectors avoid payment of taxes. Okeke et al, view informal sector as an unobserved, unorganized or unprotected economy
[12] | Okeke, C. A, Nwogwugwu, U C, Ezenekwe, R. U, Uzonwanne, M. C &Ekwoh, G. A. (2023). Inclusive Growth and Informal Sector Growth in Enugu State, Nigeria. Journal of Economics Studies, 20(1), 394-413. |
[12]
. Informal sector is often exposed to lot of challenges which may lead to insecurity within the sector. Attention of relevant tax authority is shifted from this sector as outfits, edifices and revenue size are often and reasonably low. Informal sector consists of economic activities involving production and distribution of goods and services which are not registered and regulated
[14] | Salawu, M. K., Okesina, S. O &Olabode, B. M. (2023). Determinants of Tax Non-Compliance Behaviour among Small and Medium Enterprises in Oyo State, Nigeria. Twist, 18(4), 344-353. |
[14]
. Wahua et al, view informal sector as an underground economies or traditional sectors or shadow economies as operators in them lack primary documentation to bring them into tax net
[17] | Wahua, L, Kwode, I. E, Ike, R. C & Julius, K. A. M. (2023). Review of Contemporary Best Practices in Tax Revenue Mobilization from Underground Economies. International Journal of Latest Technology in Engineerin, Management & Applied Science, 12(2), 38-48. |
[17]
. Many of Small and Medium Enterprises fall within the informal sectors
[14] | Salawu, M. K., Okesina, S. O &Olabode, B. M. (2023). Determinants of Tax Non-Compliance Behaviour among Small and Medium Enterprises in Oyo State, Nigeria. Twist, 18(4), 344-353. |
[14]
. Mpofu opines that large and expanding informal sectors place a limitation on revenue collection in developing nations
[8] | Mpofu, F. Y. (2023). Challenges affecting Informal Sector Tax Administrative Enforcement and Compliance in Africa Countries: Evidence from Zimbabwe. Journal of Accounting and Management, 13(2), -104. |
[8]
. Contributions to the tax revenue are minimal or negligible. Unavailability of data hinders relevant tax authority to assess the operators to tax. Underground economies are not registered and regulated in entirety and this make imposition of taxes impossible
[9] | Ogaluzor, O. I & Edori, D. S. (2023). Tax Education and Tax Compliance: A Study of the Informal Sector Operators in Abia and Rivers State. British International Journal of Applied Economics, Finance and Accounting, 7(4), 34-45. |
[9]
. Tax revenue maximization objective calls for more informal sectors to be brought into tax net.
2.2. Taxpayers' Awareness and Education
Taxpayers’ awareness and education is paramount to achieve tax compliance. Tax awareness is alertness of the taxpayer toward prompt payment of tax due. Ogungbade et al, describe tax awareness as consciousness, alertness and knowledge of the tax payers of their civil responsibilities to tax payment
[10] | Ogungbade, O. I., Enitan, A. & Adekoya, C. (2021). Tax Awareness, Tax payer’s Perceptions and Attitudes and Tax Evasion in Informal Sector of Ekiti State, Nigeria. International Journal of Financial Research, 12(5), 24-40. |
[10]
. Informal sector operators are not adequately informed about taxes they are to pay and the relevant tax authorities
[14] | Salawu, M. K., Okesina, S. O &Olabode, B. M. (2023). Determinants of Tax Non-Compliance Behaviour among Small and Medium Enterprises in Oyo State, Nigeria. Twist, 18(4), 344-353. |
[14]
. Many informal sector operators fall within the low income and little knowledge of business registrations
[9] | Ogaluzor, O. I & Edori, D. S. (2023). Tax Education and Tax Compliance: A Study of the Informal Sector Operators in Abia and Rivers State. British International Journal of Applied Economics, Finance and Accounting, 7(4), 34-45. |
[9]
. Tax payers' awareness and education have been affirmed by the existing to positively influence tax compliance
[9] | Ogaluzor, O. I & Edori, D. S. (2023). Tax Education and Tax Compliance: A Study of the Informal Sector Operators in Abia and Rivers State. British International Journal of Applied Economics, Finance and Accounting, 7(4), 34-45. |
[10] | Ogungbade, O. I., Enitan, A. & Adekoya, C. (2021). Tax Awareness, Tax payer’s Perceptions and Attitudes and Tax Evasion in Informal Sector of Ekiti State, Nigeria. International Journal of Financial Research, 12(5), 24-40. |
[14] | Salawu, M. K., Okesina, S. O &Olabode, B. M. (2023). Determinants of Tax Non-Compliance Behaviour among Small and Medium Enterprises in Oyo State, Nigeria. Twist, 18(4), 344-353. |
[15] | Sani, A I. (2023). Effect of Tax Compliance Determinants on Tax Evasion in Nigeria: An Empirical Insight. African Development Finance Journal, 6(1), 87-104. |
[9, 10, 14, 15].
2.3. Taxpayers' Perceptions
Taxpayer's perception is described as the view of taxpayer toward government expenditures. Government’s failure to discharge some civil responsibilities serves as negative signal to would be taxpayers. Ogungbade et al, (2023) describe tax payers' perceptions as how taxpayers view government's ways of spending tax revenue. Tax morale can only be boosted if taxpayers perceive corresponding positive economic effect of taxes. Positive perception of taxpayers has positive significant influence on tax compliance
[11] | Ogunsola, I B &Karztelnik, K. (2022). Observation Study of Tax Compliance and Tax Evasion in Nigeria. 6(5), 1-13. |
[11].
2.4. Tax Compliance
Informal sector is characterized with non tax compliance. Ogungbade et al, attribute non tax compliance of the informal sector operators due low income level and little or no information on taxes to be paid
[10] | Ogungbade, O. I., Enitan, A. & Adekoya, C. (2021). Tax Awareness, Tax payer’s Perceptions and Attitudes and Tax Evasion in Informal Sector of Ekiti State, Nigeria. International Journal of Financial Research, 12(5), 24-40. |
[10]
. Salawu et al, opine that non tax compliance among the Small and Medium Enterprises are functions of tax compliance costs and corruption of tax officials and administrators
[14] | Salawu, M. K., Okesina, S. O &Olabode, B. M. (2023). Determinants of Tax Non-Compliance Behaviour among Small and Medium Enterprises in Oyo State, Nigeria. Twist, 18(4), 344-353. |
[14]
. Ogunsola & Karztelnik, opines that fail to submit tax return lead to tax evasion
[11] | Ogunsola, I B &Karztelnik, K. (2022). Observation Study of Tax Compliance and Tax Evasion in Nigeria. 6(5), 1-13. |
[11]
. Many informal operators are non regulated shadow economies which are often non registered for tax payment
[17] | Wahua, L, Kwode, I. E, Ike, R. C & Julius, K. A. M. (2023). Review of Contemporary Best Practices in Tax Revenue Mobilization from Underground Economies. International Journal of Latest Technology in Engineerin, Management & Applied Science, 12(2), 38-48. |
[17]
Tax education, tax knowledge, tax audit, taxpayer attitudes are considered to positively influence tax compliance among the informal sector operators
[9] | Ogaluzor, O. I & Edori, D. S. (2023). Tax Education and Tax Compliance: A Study of the Informal Sector Operators in Abia and Rivers State. British International Journal of Applied Economics, Finance and Accounting, 7(4), 34-45. |
[10] | Ogungbade, O. I., Enitan, A. & Adekoya, C. (2021). Tax Awareness, Tax payer’s Perceptions and Attitudes and Tax Evasion in Informal Sector of Ekiti State, Nigeria. International Journal of Financial Research, 12(5), 24-40. |
[14] | Salawu, M. K., Okesina, S. O &Olabode, B. M. (2023). Determinants of Tax Non-Compliance Behaviour among Small and Medium Enterprises in Oyo State, Nigeria. Twist, 18(4), 344-353. |
[15] | Sani, A I. (2023). Effect of Tax Compliance Determinants on Tax Evasion in Nigeria: An Empirical Insight. African Development Finance Journal, 6(1), 87-104. |
[16] | Tijjani, H, Ibrahim, A S, Ardo, A. M & Yusuf, A U. (2023). The Impact of Forensic Accounting on Tax Payer Attitude and Compliance towards Tax Evasion within SMEs in the North East Nigeria. Journal of Business & Management, 13(1), 79-105. |
[9, 10, 14-16]
. Wahua et al and Moore, affirm that formalization and registration of informal sectors enhance the tax compliance among the operators
[7] | Moore, M. (2022). Tax Obsessions: Tax Registration and the Informal Sector in Sub-Saharan Africa. www.wileyonlinelibrary.org retrieved on 3rd March, 2024. |
[17] | Wahua, L, Kwode, I. E, Ike, R. C & Julius, K. A. M. (2023). Review of Contemporary Best Practices in Tax Revenue Mobilization from Underground Economies. International Journal of Latest Technology in Engineerin, Management & Applied Science, 12(2), 38-48. |
[7, 17]
.
2.5. Theoretical Framework
The following theories are reviewed: Theory of Reasoned Action, Planned Behavioural theory and Fiscal Exchange Theory. Theory of Reasoned Action was propounded by Fishbein and Azjen (1975). Fishbein and Azjenproposed that an intention or action is created when individual attitude and behaviour coexisted
[3] | Ajzen, I. (1985). From Intentions to Actions: A Theory of Planned Behaviour, J. Kuhl & J. Beckham (Eds), 11- 39, Heidelberg, Springer. |
[5] | Fishbein, M & Ajzen, I. (1975). Theory of Reasoned Action: Some Applications and Implication. www.psycnet.apa.org |
[3, 5]
. Ogunshola & Kasztelnik adopted this theory and opined that personality traits of individuals have influence on tax compliance
[11] | Ogunsola, I B &Karztelnik, K. (2022). Observation Study of Tax Compliance and Tax Evasion in Nigeria. 6(5), 1-13. |
[11]
. This study suggests that tax compliance among the informal sector operators depends on the perception or attitude of the individual operator toward tax payment. The theory reflected the relationship between objective and subjected norms which represent individual's perception in the ability to achieve the intention. The theory only considered perceptions of tax payers which influence tax compliance. Other factors such tax education, tax knowledge, tax audit etc can also influence tax compliance. Planned Behavioural Theory was modified by Azjen,
[4] | Akinyiga, A. A. (2021). Tax Revenue to Gross Domestic Product Ratio. FIRS Quarterly Report. |
[4]
. The theory proposes that a specific behaviour is not dependent on intention but on the belief that individual's ability to do such behaviour
[9] | Ogaluzor, O. I & Edori, D. S. (2023). Tax Education and Tax Compliance: A Study of the Informal Sector Operators in Abia and Rivers State. British International Journal of Applied Economics, Finance and Accounting, 7(4), 34-45. |
[9]
. Behaviour of the taxpayer must be to comply with the government legislations on tax
[15] | Sani, A I. (2023). Effect of Tax Compliance Determinants on Tax Evasion in Nigeria: An Empirical Insight. African Development Finance Journal, 6(1), 87-104. |
[15]
. The attitude or behaviour of the taxpayers has effect on intention to comply with tax regulations
[9] | Ogaluzor, O. I & Edori, D. S. (2023). Tax Education and Tax Compliance: A Study of the Informal Sector Operators in Abia and Rivers State. British International Journal of Applied Economics, Finance and Accounting, 7(4), 34-45. |
[15] | Sani, A I. (2023). Effect of Tax Compliance Determinants on Tax Evasion in Nigeria: An Empirical Insight. African Development Finance Journal, 6(1), 87-104. |
[9, 15]
. This theory is a modification to the Fishbein &Azjen theory of Reasoned Action. The theory only projected the taxpayers’ behaviours and attitudes. Another theory reviews in the study is Fiscal Exchange Theory. The theory was propounded by Mckerchar & Evan
[6] | McKerchar, M. A. & Evans, C. (2009). Sustaining Growth in Developing Economies through improved Taxpayers Compliance: Challenges for Policy Makers and Revenue. Paper presented at 21st Australian Tax Teachers Annual Conference University of Canterbury. |
[6]
. The theory assumed that taxpayers comply with relevant tax laws when they are satisfied with goods and services provided by the government
[8] | Mpofu, F. Y. (2023). Challenges affecting Informal Sector Tax Administrative Enforcement and Compliance in Africa Countries: Evidence from Zimbabwe. Journal of Accounting and Management, 13(2), -104. |
[8]
. This theory is relevant because it combines the responsibilities of both government and tax payers. Informal sectors operators will be willing to comply with tax laws if they are perceive that all tax revenue are judiciously utilized by government. This study is therefore grounded on the theory of Fiscal Exchange Theory. Tax Compliance can be achieved from the informal sectors if the operators are satisfied with public goods and services provided by the government.
2.6. Empirical Review
The following literatures are review to determine the state of research on the subject matter:
Ogungbade et al. investigate the effect of tax awareness and taxpayer's perception of government spending on tax evasion in informal sector of Ekiti State. A structured questionnaire was used to collect data from 150 respondents, 108 returned the completed questionnaires out of which only 100 respondents data were useful for analysis. The findings show that the taxpayer's awareness considerably reduced tax evasion while tax payers' attitudes only have significant moderating effect on the relationship between taxpayers' awareness and tax evasion
[10] | Ogungbade, O. I., Enitan, A. & Adekoya, C. (2021). Tax Awareness, Tax payer’s Perceptions and Attitudes and Tax Evasion in Informal Sector of Ekiti State, Nigeria. International Journal of Financial Research, 12(5), 24-40. |
[10]
.
Moore examines the tax obsessions: tax payer registration and the informal sector in Sub Saharan Africa. The study adopts desk research by reviewing the existing literatures. Findings reveal three features of tax systems that are necessary to be examined in Sub Saharan Africa countries: Registration of more taxpayers, management efforts to collect more revenue and constantly use of the word informal sector lead to tax obsession among the operators
[7] | Moore, M. (2022). Tax Obsessions: Tax Registration and the Informal Sector in Sub-Saharan Africa. www.wileyonlinelibrary.org retrieved on 3rd March, 2024. |
[7]
.
Ogunsola & Karztelnik explore observational study on tax compliance and tax evasion in Nigeria. Methods of generalization, analysis and synthesis of scientific literature, formalization and abstraction are adopted in the study. The article presents the results of an empirical analysis revealed that manufacturing companies deliberately fail to submit the required tax return documentation to avoid tax obligations
[11] | Ogunsola, I B &Karztelnik, K. (2022). Observation Study of Tax Compliance and Tax Evasion in Nigeria. 6(5), 1-13. |
[11]
.
Sani investigates the effects of the tax compliance determinant on tax evasion in Nigeria. The study employed a survey design research approach to achieve the stated objective. A quantitative method was used. Data were collected using a structured questionnaire from a sample of SME operators in six states in North Eastern, North Central Zones and FCT Abuja. Tax morale, tax education and TH have positive impact on the tax compliance of taxpayers' while TD has negative impact
[15] | Sani, A I. (2023). Effect of Tax Compliance Determinants on Tax Evasion in Nigeria: An Empirical Insight. African Development Finance Journal, 6(1), 87-104. |
[15]
.
Mpofu studies challenges affecting informal sector tax administration, enforcement and compliance in African countries: Evidence from Zimbabwe. The study employed a sequential mixed method exploratory research design which supports the collection of qualitative data from various stakeholders using interviews observation and document analysis, supported by questionnaires for the quantitative part. The study employed thematic analysis with the use of NVVO Pro. 12 for the interview and SPSS for questionnaires. Findings reveal that information sector's potential to contribute more is stifled by structural and policy issues embedded in the existing tax systems such as complexity of tax systems, stakeholders’ engagement, high tax rates and aggressiveness of tax authorities
[7] | Moore, M. (2022). Tax Obsessions: Tax Registration and the Informal Sector in Sub-Saharan Africa. www.wileyonlinelibrary.org retrieved on 3rd March, 2024. |
[7]
.
Wahua et al. explore best practices in the revenue mobilization from underground economies. The study used primary data collected from online sources using phrases such as tax collection from informal sectors, tax revenue collection from shadow economies, Taxation of underground economies. The study revealed that indirect taxes, WHT, presumptive taxes and formalization of informal sectors are the international best practices in tax revenue mobilization from underground economies
[17] | Wahua, L, Kwode, I. E, Ike, R. C & Julius, K. A. M. (2023). Review of Contemporary Best Practices in Tax Revenue Mobilization from Underground Economies. International Journal of Latest Technology in Engineerin, Management & Applied Science, 12(2), 38-48. |
[17]
.
Tijjani et al study the impact of forensic accounting on tax payer attitude and compliance towards tax evasion within SMEs in the North East Nigeria. Cross sectional research design was used with data collected using simple random sampling. With the help of Smart PLS 3, Partial Least Square Structural Equation Modelling on 102 responses was utilizes to evaluate the data. The findings revealed that a forensic accounting check is required to address the issue of tax evasion in Nigeria to ensure a good attitude and compliance. Forensic accounting improves taxpayers’ attitude and tax compliance
[16] | Tijjani, H, Ibrahim, A S, Ardo, A. M & Yusuf, A U. (2023). The Impact of Forensic Accounting on Tax Payer Attitude and Compliance towards Tax Evasion within SMEs in the North East Nigeria. Journal of Business & Management, 13(1), 79-105. |
[16]
.
Salawu et al. examine the determinants of tax non compliance behaviour among small and medium enterprises in Oyo State, Nigeria. Primary data were gathered using structured questionnaires for samples of 550 SMEs operators randomly selected within three local government areas in Ibadan the capital city of Oyo State. Descriptive statistics and probit logistic regression technique were used to analyze the data. The findings revealed that corruption of tax officials and administrators and tax compliance costs are the major determinants of tax non compliance. Tax knowledge, tax audit, tax penalty and tax amnesty are found to reduce tax non compliance among the SMEs taxpayers in Oyo State
[14] | Salawu, M. K., Okesina, S. O &Olabode, B. M. (2023). Determinants of Tax Non-Compliance Behaviour among Small and Medium Enterprises in Oyo State, Nigeria. Twist, 18(4), 344-353. |
[14]
.
Ogaluzor and Edori study the effect of tax education on tax compliance of informal sector operators in Abia and Rivers States. The study adopts the survey research design and select 120 respondents as sample size operating within the informal sector. The Pearson correlation was used in analyzing the 114 returned questionnaires retrieved. The study results show significant relationship between electronic taxpayer education, stakeholder's sensitization, print media taxpayer education and registration of new taxpayers timelyreturns filing, prompt payment of tax liabilities at a significant level 0.00
[9] | Ogaluzor, O. I & Edori, D. S. (2023). Tax Education and Tax Compliance: A Study of the Informal Sector Operators in Abia and Rivers State. British International Journal of Applied Economics, Finance and Accounting, 7(4), 34-45. |
[9]
.
2.7. Gaps in the Literatures
Oyo North Senatorial district considerably harbours majority of informal sectors operators in Oyo State with major commercial cities like Ogbomoso, Iseyin and Saki. Existing literatures such Salawu et al and Ogungbade et al concentrated on the capital cities of the states which are Ibadan and Ado Ekiti respectively
[11] | Ogunsola, I B &Karztelnik, K. (2022). Observation Study of Tax Compliance and Tax Evasion in Nigeria. 6(5), 1-13. |
[14] | Salawu, M. K., Okesina, S. O &Olabode, B. M. (2023). Determinants of Tax Non-Compliance Behaviour among Small and Medium Enterprises in Oyo State, Nigeria. Twist, 18(4), 344-353. |
[11, 14]
. Informal sectors like fashion designers, grinders, mansioners, carpenters and Barbers and Hairdressers in these major cities of the Senatorial district are often escaped the net of the relevant tax authorities. Low tax compliance from these categories have not been investigated in Oyo North Senatorial Districts.
4. Data Analysis Results
The above
Table 1. showed demographic distributions of the selected informal sector operators selected from Tailors, Builders, Plumbers, Hair dressers/Barbers, Welders and vulcanizers in Ogbomoso, Iseyin and Saki Zones respectively. 975 questionnaires were administered but 823 questionnaires were properly filled and returned by the respondents. Therefore the data analysis is based on the data gathered from 823 respondents.
Interpretation
The above table showed the demographic distributions of the respondents. 230 (27.9%) respondents were tailors, 106 (12.9%) respondents were Bricklayers, 95 (11.5%) respondents were in plumbing business, 132 (16%) were inweldering business and 149 (18.1%) were in vulcanizing business. This indicated that the majority of informal sector operators who successfully filled the questionnaires were in tailoring business. Gender distribution were investigated, 230 (27.9%) respondents are male while 593 (72.15) respondents are female. This indicated that majority of informal sector operators in Oyo North Senatorial District are female.
Age distribution of the informal sector operators was also examined. The study revealed that 10 (1.2%) respondents fall with the age of 21-30 years, 10 (1.2%) respondents are within the age bracket of 31-40 years, 87 (10.6%) respondents are within age brackets of 41-50 yearswhile 716 (87.0%) respondents are within the age bracket of 51-60 years. This indicated that majority of informal sector operators within Oyo North Senatorial District are above 50 years.
4.1. Demographic Distribution
Table 1. Demographic Distribution.
Business Name | Frequency | Percent | Valid Percent | Cumulative Percent |
Tailors | 230 | 27.9 | 27.9 | 27.9 |
Bricklayers/Builders | 106 | 12.9 | 12.9 | 40.8 |
Plumbers | 95 | 11.5 | 11.5 | 52.4 |
Hair Saloon | 111 | 13.5 | 13.5 | 65.9 |
Welders | 132 | 16.0 | 16.0 | 81.9 |
Vulcanizers | 149 | 18.1 | 18.1 | 100.0 |
Gender | | | | |
Male | 230 | 27.9 | 27.9 | 27.9 |
Female | 593 | 72.1 | 72.1 | 100.0 |
Age | | | | |
21-30 years | 10 | 1.2 | 1.2 | 1.2 |
31-40 years | 10 | 1.2 | 1.2 | 2.4 |
41-50 years | 87 | 10.6 | 10.6 | 13.0 |
Academic Qualifications | | | | |
SSCE | 655 | 79.6 | 79.6 | 79.6 |
ND/NCE | 100 | 12.2 | 12.2 | 91.7 |
B.Sc/HND | 68 | 8.3 | 8.3 | 100.0 |
Experiences | | | | |
1-5 years | 490 | 59.5 | 59.5 | 59.5 |
6-10 years | 327 | 39.7 | 39.7 | 99.3 |
11-20 years | 6 | .7 | .7 | 100.0 |
Source: Researchers’ Field Work, 2025
The study showed that 655 (79.6%) respondents are Senior Secondary holders, 100 (12.2%) respondents are ND/NCE holders and 68 (8.3%) respondents are B. Sc/HND holders. The study concluded that majority of the informal sector operators are SSCE holders. Although informal sectors were characterized with illiteracy, but however, the some educated individuals take solace in Small and Medium Enterprises.
The study revealed that 490 (59.5%) respondents have been in the business for 5 years, 327 (39.7%) respondents have been in the business between period of 6 and 10 years, 6 (0.7%) respondents have in business between period of 11-20 years. The study therefore concluded that majority of the respondents have been in the informal sectors for more than five years.
4.2. Reliability Test
The Alpha Cronbach test revealed that all research questions outlined in the questionnaires are 56.7% reliable.
4.3. Test of Hypothesis
4.3.1. Test of Hypothesis One
Taxpayers’ awareness and education have no significant impact on informal sector tax compliance in Oyo North Senatorial District.
Table 2. Model summary.
Model Summary |
Model | R | R Square | Adjusted R Square | Std. Error of the Estimate |
1 | .192a | .037 | .036 | 1.14478 |
a. Predictors: (Constant), Tax payers’ Awareness |
The above
Table 2. showed for test of goodness of fit of the model. The Adjusted R
2 is 0.036% which indicates that taxpayers’ awareness can explain about 3.6% of the changes in informal sector tax compliance in Oyo North Senatorial District. Other variables which are not captured in this study constitute about 96.4%. Therefore the Ho which proposes that the model does not satisfy the test of goodness fit is upheld. R also indicates the relationship between taxpayers’ awareness and tax compliance. This suggested that there is lower positive relationship between taxpayers and tax compliance, which is represented by 19.2%.
Table 3. Coefficients.
Coefficientsa |
Model | Unstandardized Coefficients | Standardized Coefficients | t | Sig. |
B | Std. Error | Beta |
1 | (Constant) | 2.781 | .105 | | 26.370 | .000 |
Taxpayers’ awareness | 0.144 | .026 | -.192 | -5.611 | .000 |
a. Dependent Variable: Tax Compliance |
The above table shows the coefficient table reflecting the impact of tax payers’ awareness which on informal sector tax compliance in Oyo North Senatorial District. Taxpayers’ awareness has positive and significant effect on tax compliance of β = 0.144 at PV> 0.05. This shows that as tax awareness increases the tax compliance increases significantly
The model to be formulated from above is
Table 4. ANOVA.
ANOVAa |
Model | Sum of Squares | df | Mean Square | F | Sig. |
1 | Regression | 41.261 | 1 | 41.261 | 31.484 | .000b |
Residual | 1075.947 | 821 | 1.311 | | |
Total | 1117.208 | 822 | | | |
a. Dependent Variable: Tax Compliance |
b. Predictors: (Constant), Tax payers’ Awareness |
The above table shows the analysis of variance. The F-value= 31.484 (p>0.05). This indicates that the H0 which assumes that taxpayers’ awareness has no significant effect on tax compliance of the informal sectors in Oyo North Senatorial District is hereby declined while Hi is upheld. It is therefore concluded that Taxpayers’ awareness has significant impact on tax compliance of informal sectors in Oyo North Senatorial District
4.3.2. Test of Hypothesis Two
Table 5. Model Summary.
Tax payers’ perception has no significant impact of informal sector tax compliance in Oyo North Senatorial District |
Model | R | R Square | Adjusted R Square | Std. Error of the Estimate |
1 | .206a | .043 | .041 | 1.14141 |
a. Predictors: (Constant), Tax payers’ Perceptions |
The above showed the table for test of goodness of fit of the model. The Adjusted R2 is 0.043% which indicates that taxpayers’ perceptions can explain about 4.3% of the changes in informal sector tax compliance in Oyo North Senatorial District. Other variables which are not captured in this study constitute about 95.7%. Therefore the Ho which proposes that the model does not satisfy the test of goodness fit is upheld. R also indicates the relationship between taxpayers’ perceptions and tax compliance. This suggested that there is lower positive relationship between taxpayers’ perceptions and tax compliance, which is represented by 20.6%.
Table 6. Coefficients.
Coefficientsa |
Model | Unstandardized Coefficients | Standardized Coefficients | t | Sig. |
B | Std. Error | Beta |
1 | (Constant) | 1.179 | .179 | | 6.587 | .000 |
Taxpayers’ Perception | .588 | .097 | .206 | 6.045 | .000 |
a. Dependent Variable: Tax Compliance |
The above table shows the coefficient table reflecting the impact of tax payers’ perceptions which on informal sector tax compliance in Oyo North Senatorial District. Taxpayers’ perception has positive and significant effect on tax compliance of β = 0.588 at PV> 0.05. This shows that changes in tax perceptions lead to corresponding changes in informal sectors’ tax compliance significantly.
The model to be formulated from above is
Table 7. Analysis of Variance.
ANOVAa |
Model | Sum of Squares | df | Mean Square | F | Sig. |
1 | Regression | 47.601 | 1 | 47.601 | 36.537 | .000b |
Residual | 1069.607 | 821 | 1.303 | | |
Total | 1117.208 | 822 | | | |
a. Dependent Variable: Tax Compliance |
b. Predictors: (Constant), Taxpayers’ Perceptions |
The above table shows the analysis of variance. The F-value= 36.537 (p>0.05). This indicates that the H0 which assumes that taxpayers’ perceptions have no significant effect on tax compliance of the informal sectors in Oyo North Senatorial District is hereby declined while Hi is upheld. It is therefore concluded that Taxpayers’ perceptions have significant impact on tax compliance of informal sectors in Oyo North Senatorial District.
4.4. Discussion of Findings
The study had empirically tested the impact of taxpayers’ awareness and perceptions on the level of tax compliance among the informal sector’s operators in Oyo North Senatorial District, Oyo State. The study established that taxpayers’ awareness and their perceptions about the tax payments influenced tax compliance. This study outcome was in line with studies of Salawu
et al, and Ogungbade
et al [1] | Abdu, A. M. and Wondimu, S. (2019). Analysis of Tax Compliance and its Determinants: Evidence from Kaffa, Bendi, Maji and Sheka Zones Category B Taxpayers, SNNPR, Ethiopia. Journal of Accounting, Finance and Auditing Studies, 5(1), 32-58. |
[11] | Ogunsola, I B &Karztelnik, K. (2022). Observation Study of Tax Compliance and Tax Evasion in Nigeria. 6(5), 1-13. |
[1, 11]
. Taxpayers are not adequately informed and educated on the relevant tax information. Informal sector or shadow economy as often called are not duly registered and this constitute to low tax compliance. Many taxpayers within the informal sectors viewed taxes as money paid for the corrupt public office holders. Inadequate and absence of infrastructural facilities in the domain of these operators lead to massive evasion of taxes.